> My solution would be to make a new hard set of rules that is able to cover every > situation we've run into that can be pointed to that covers every situation as > objectively as possible. It would have to be written over time most likely within > mamedev mailing list but the judge system is not logical according to Spock.
hard and fast rules can be damaging, there are always other factors to consider.
we tried hard and fast rules in the past, stuff ended up being lost / removed that shouldn't have been.