MAMEWorld >> EmuChat
View all threads Index   Threaded Mode Threaded  

Pages: 1

taz-nz
MAME Fan
Reged: 11/26/07
Posts: 125
Send PM


MAME 0.229 benchmarks AMD Ryzen 7 5800X vs Intel i7-11700K
#390439 - 03/26/21 09:10 AM


After 3 months of waiting for RAM, I've just upgraded by PC to a AMD Ryzen 7 5800X, and today had the opportunity to have a play with a new Intel core i7-11700K setup. (Full system specs below.)


Game		AMD 5800X	Intel 11700K	    Difference
blitz 368.46 346.29 -6.02%
crusnusa 388.06 442.85 14.12%
cubeqst 461.80 462.58 0.17%
cyvern 1468.45 1623.78 10.58%
dkong 5737.71 5991.90 4.43%
drivedge 455.91 492.75 8.08%
gauntleg 583.26 557.64 -4.39%
gnbarich 2437.31 2776.38 13.91%
gradius4 568.67 515.92 -9.28%
gtfore06 288.71 274.07 -5.07%
harddriv 841.44 891.12 5.90%
kidniki 586.75 603.03 2.77%
kof98 1755.84 1821.26 3.73%
mario 1346.96 1491.03 10.70%
mk4 333.00 377.97 13.50%
pacman 15089.09 18205.31 20.65%
pinkswts 2417.71 2551.19 5.52%
pongf 589.76 648.20 9.91%
propcycl 381.93 349.80 -8.41%
radikalb 324.21 351.32 8.36%
roadblst 1421.72 1468.47 3.29%
robotron 7625.14 8681.59 13.85%
rvschool 469.97 592.62 26.10%
scud 135.48 113.16 -16.47%
sf2 3555.88 3844.65 8.12%
sfa2 2333.74 2655.14 13.77%
sfiii 2019.58 2097.66 3.87%
slrasslt 713.01 785.28 10.14%
spacfury 245.20 244.37 -0.34%
starblad 257.02 269.07 4.69%
starsldr 78.28 92.83 18.59%
sushibar 121.31 120.08 -1.01%
tekken 693.02 847.02 22.22%
tekken3 361.93 439.12 21.33%
vf2 237.27 238.31 0.44%
vfkids 186.99 193.61 3.54%
-------
Average Difference 6.42%


Benchmarks were preformed with Arcade MAME 64bit v0.229. (all roms were run normally before starting benchmark run to make sure they were configured correctly with no errors or stops that would effect run)

On fresh installs of Windows 10 Pro, 202H will all updates and latest drivers for both systems, as of 26/03/2021. Windows power profile was set to Performance, but otherwise stock install.

AMD System:
CPU: Ryzen 7 5800X (PBO +200Mhz, FCLK 1900)
MB: Gigabyte B550 PRO AX (BIOS F13g)
RAM: G.SKill DDR4-3800 CL14, 32GB 2x16GB Dual Rank DIMMs
Custom Water cooling loop.

Intel System:
CPU: Core i7-11700K (stock other RAM set to Gear Mode 1)
MB: Gigabyte Z590 Gaming X (BIOS F3)
RAM: G.Skill DDR4-3600 CL16, 32GB 2x16GB Dual Rank DIMMs
Corsair H115i 280mm AIO fans & pump set to max speed.

It may look like Intel system is at a disadvantage due to slower RAM, but currently available information for 11 Gen Intel CPUs points to little to no performance scaling with RAM over DDR4-3200 CL16.



TrevEB, sorry for no replying to you question until now, my PC is been spread over my living room floor for the last couple of weeks.

I just use a simple Batch file with the command Bench [Rom Name] with runs the benchmark and output the result to a txt file with the [Rom Name].txt in a folder called Bench.

Once I've run all the benchmarks I open each of the txt file and copy the scores into Google spreadsheet. I then copy it into note pad to do some very basic formatting before posting here.

I did have much more complex batch file setup at one time, that processed the list of Rom name and benchmark then it turn coping the result to a single txt file with basic formatting. But it was lost somewhere along the way in a hard disk shuffle, and most of my ancient batch writing skills have now faded away to the point I haven't been motivated enough to reconstruct it.



If all else fails, Burn the manual.



John IV
IV/Play, MAME, MAMEUI
Reged: 09/22/03
Posts: 1969
Loc: Washington, USA
Send PM


Re: MAME 0.229 benchmarks AMD Ryzen 7 5800X vs Intel i7-11700K new [Re: taz-nz]
#390447 - 03/27/21 07:27 AM


Nice, still at 4.7Ghz and 5Ghz?
Any reason for not using the mamedev .exe?

Added your runs to the spreadsheet, thanks -
http://www.mameui.info/Bench.htm

Edited by John IV (03/27/21 09:34 AM)



john iv
http://www.mameui.info/



andreol263
MAME Fan
Reged: 05/27/17
Posts: 17
Send PM


Re: MAME 0.229 benchmarks AMD Ryzen 7 5800X vs Intel i7-11700K new [Re: taz-nz]
#390465 - 03/29/21 04:59 AM


Scud Racer is really running above 100% on these CPUs? Amazing stuff, do you think that going from a Ryzen 3600 to a 5600x is gonna make a big difference for MAME?



PC: Ryzen 3600 4.2Ghz, 16GB DDR4, RTX 2070 SUPER



taz-nz
MAME Fan
Reged: 11/26/07
Posts: 125
Send PM


Re: MAME 0.229 benchmarks AMD Ryzen 7 5800X vs Intel i7-11700K new [Re: andreol263]
#390466 - 03/29/21 10:31 AM


The bench command produces a result for unthrottled average performance, so can be deceptive, while the average for Scud Racing is over 100% it still dips in the 70s in places.

Given that the emulation of Scud is incomplete and there are noticeable graphics issues, future work by the devs could swing performance in either direction, I wouldn't upgrade for this game alone.

The ZEN 3 IPC performance gains and the single unified cache help a lot in MAME, but if you already have Ryzen 5 3600 CPU I'd probably wait for ZEN 4 which will likely bring larger gains.

I'm still chasing the day CPU performance lets Dolphin blue hits a solid 100%.



If all else fails, Burn the manual.



taz-nz
MAME Fan
Reged: 11/26/07
Posts: 125
Send PM


Re: MAME 0.229 benchmarks AMD Ryzen 7 5800X vs Intel i7-11700K new [Re: John IV]
#390467 - 03/29/21 10:42 AM


I typically run Acrade MAME for my personal use, and I forgot I had modded benchmark file to use that exe, the performance difference between and official MAME and arcade MAME are minimal, so didn't bother to re run benchmark.

My previous run on the Ryzen 5 5800x on 0.226 had a few issues so some of those number are probably wrong, I've since rebuilt my ROM set and used clean install of MAME to and re-setup games.



If all else fails, Burn the manual.


Pages: 1

MAMEWorld >> EmuChat
View all threads Index   Threaded Mode Threaded  

Extra information Permissions
Moderator:  Robbbert, Tafoid 
0 registered and 343 anonymous users are browsing this forum.
You cannot start new topics
You cannot reply to topics
HTML is enabled
UBBCode is enabled
Thread views: 667